WARNING: This post contains MAJOR SPOILERS for “Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life,” and reveals the infamous “final four words.” Do not read on if you have not watched and do not want to be spoiled.
If you’re a “Gilmore Girls” obsessive, you probably spent the day after Thanksgiving enjoying your leftovers with a hefty helping of binge-watching, too, devouring the four installments of Netflix revival series “Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life.” It was wonderful and a bit surreal to suddenly be back in Stars Hollow, picking up with Lorelai, Rory, and Emily nine years after the original show signed off, and finding out just where life had taken them in the time since we last saw them on our television screens.
With any revival of a long-dormant, much-beloved series, there are bound to be things that both delight and disappoint viewers in equal measure, and “A Year in the Life” was chock full of that dichotomy. Seeing Rory and Lorelai banter about coffee and pop culture again was great; seeing Rory cheat on her boyfriend with an engaged Logan, not so much. Discovering that Emily was born to be a museum docent (and swear up a storm in front of her buttoned-up DAR pals) may have been the best thing about the revival; finding out that Paris and Doyle are getting divorced, or that Lane had almost no lines at all, made us pretty sad.
But the biggest — and most divisive — plot line was saved for the very end of the series, with the last scene in “Fall” finally delivering the long-anticipated, much-hyped, now-legendary “final four words,” with which “Gilmore” creator Amy Sherman-Palladino intended to end the original series before departing amid a contract dispute ahead of season seven. Here they are, as delivered by Rory (Alexis Bledel) and Lorelai (Lauren Graham):
Rory: Mom?
Lorelai: Yeah?
Rory: I’m pregnant.
That shocking mother-daughter exchange raises some major questions not only for the characters themselves, but the future of “Gilmore Girls” going forward. Let’s break down the biggest talking points:
Who’s the father?
The answer to this one seems pretty straightforward, since Rory was consistently sleeping with Logan (Matt Czuchry) throughout “Winter,” “Spring,” “Summer,” and “Fall,” and only finally broke up with him for good a few weeks before making her big announcement at the end of “Fall.” And her pregnancy sheds some new light on an earlier scene with her father, Christopher (David Sutcliffe), in which Rory asks if he regretted letting Lorelai raise Rory on her own, indicating she’s debating whether or not she wants to involve Logan at all in her pregnancy and the baby’s life.
Still, there are some who wonder if perhaps Rory’s sad sack boyfriend Paul is the father (a possibility we’re ruling out, since Rory never had time to see him, let alone sleep with — or break up with — him throughout the revival), or maybe that Wookiee she slept with while reporting her lines story (a timeline that just doesn’t work out, based on the season of her pregnancy announcement). The most popular dueling theory is that Rory could be serving as a surrogate for Lorelai and Luke, using Paris’s services to give her mom and new step-dad a baby. Judging by the surprise on Lorelai’s face, though, and the urgency in Rory’s voice when she broke the news to her mother, it certainly doesn’t seem like a likely scenario (or that this pregnancy was planned). Logan is almost definitely the daddy.
What would have happened if the words were actually used when Amy Sherman-Palladino intended?
As noted above, much has been made about Sherman-Palladino having intended to use these words to end the show’s original run. But if she had stayed on through season seven (the show’s last before getting canceled by The CW), would it have made sense for Rory to get pregnant then? After all, she would have just graduated from Yale and been only 22 at the time. Would Logan have been the father? And would they have still been together, rather than breaking up after a rejected marriage proposal? A pregnancy would have made things a bit tricky for the aspiring journalist, fresh out of college and just beginning her career. Then again, at 22, and with a prestigious degree under her belt, Rory had many more options (and a lot more emotional and financial support) available to her than her mom did when she got pregnant at 16.
As part of her contract dispute that prompted her exit, Sherman-Palladino had wanted an eighth season to wrap up the story; perhaps she would have used those extra episodes to skip ahead into the future a bit, setting Rory up for a slightly easier time as a single mom. We’ll never know, but it’s certainly an intriguing aspect of the reveal to ponder.
Does this mean the show will continue? And should it?
Not even Sherman-Palladino knows yet whether or not we’ll get another season of “A Year in the Life,” and honestly, we’re not sure whether or not we want one. On the one hand, of course, seeing more from Stars Hollow — and getting some more resolution to Rory’s story line — is certainly a welcome prospect. On the other, Rory’s revelation is truly a full-circle moment, a Gilmore girl potentially giving life to another Gilmore girl, and following in her mother’s footsteps. (Not to mention the finality of Lorelai and Emily’s story lines, with each of them seeming to come to terms with where they are in life, and finding personal peace.) And not for nothing, but it was always ASP’s intention to have things end this way, finally and definitively.
But excitement for the revival was ridiculously high, and while the notoriously secretive Netflix probably won’t be divulging viewing numbers, we feel confident that rabid “Gilmore” fans watched the new episodes in droves. It would be a no-brainer, then, for the streaming service to order up another installment of “A Year in the Life.” Sherman-Palladino has hedged her bets a bit, telling The Hollywood Reporter that she wants to see how the revival performs before thinking about making more.
“We really had a very specific journey in our minds and we fulfilled the journey. So to us, this is the piece that we wanted to do. And the whole thought about, is there more, is there more, is there more — this has to go out into the universe now,” she told THR. “And then whatever happens, happens.”
Actress Kelly Bishop, who plays Emily, told the trade that wherever Sherman-Palladino led, she would follow (meaning she’d definitely do more episodes), while Scott Patterson, who plays Luke, said that he’d be willing to sign up to do additional installments every year or two. But even Patterson admitted that there was some finality to the end of “Fall.”
“It was really rewarding and people got a sense that if this was going to be the last thing, that we now have some closure,” the actor told THR.
Setting the final four words aside, there are still plenty of questions and plot holes that we’d like to see addressed should “A Year in the Life” get another order. A.V. Club critic Myles McNutt has suggested that there be more focus put on the supporting “Gilmore” characters (we’re most interested in actually catching up with Lane, and perhaps seeing Paris and Doyle reunite). And that final look that Jess (Milo Ventimiglia) gave Rory in “Fall” indicates that he’s still carrying a torch for her, setting up a future season in which they finally give their relationship another try as adults. (A popular fan theory is that Logan is Rory’s Christopher, while Jess is her Luke.)
The jury is still out, though your personal opinion on the matter may depend most heavily on your answer to the next question.
Was the ending even good?
This will probably be the biggest debate among “Gilmore” fans, and we don’t see the discussion over it ending anytime soon. For some, it makes perfect sense (see the full circle argument above). For others, it seemed like a cheap (and some say predictable) twist. It’s hard to judge “A Year in the Life” on its own merits without factoring in the final four words — they really do color much of the revival differently once you know them — but we’d say that overall, we’re certainly happy that it exists. (Again, the greatness of Emily’s DAR rant can’t be understated.) And no matter what you think about that last bit of dialogue, it’s gotten us obsessing over “Gilmore Girls” all over again, after so many years without our beloved show. We’ll raise a steaming mug of coffee to that any day.
Photo credit: Saeed Adyani/Netflix
At long last, the premiere of Gilmore Girls” revival series, “Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life,” is finally upon us, and with it, the return of our beloved Lorelai, Rory, Emily, Luke, Sookie, Paris, and the
1. Lorelai and Luke are still together — but in a rut
2. Rory’s journalism career isn’t going well
3. Emily is rebuilding her life after Richard’s death
4. All of Rory’s boyfriends are back
5. Stars Hollow is as quirky as ever
6. Sookie is back!
7. Those final four words will be satisfying — but also controversial
Which fictional family should you break bread with this Thanksgiving? Take our handy quiz and find out the TV household that best suits your Turkey Day needs. 
When we last saw Lorelai Gilmore, she was bidding farewell to Rory, who was off to start her journalism career. As she grappled with the thought of going months without seeing her daughter, Lorelai decided to extend an olive branch to her parents, and continue the Friday night dinner tradition in Rory’s absence. With business booming at the Dragonfly (hello, celebrity guest Christiane Amanpour), Lorelai was in a great place professionally. And after her “I Will Always Love You” serenade, she and Luke officially rekindled their relationship with a big, romantic kiss.
After some false starts (and fresh off a painful breakup with Logan), Rory finally landed her first post-college journalism job, covering then-Senator Barack Obama’s burgeoning presidential campaign for an online magazine. The gig required her to crisscross the country — and leave her mom and Stars Hollow behind on only a few days’ notice. The town came together to throw her a surprise going away party, complete with heartfelt tributes from all of the colorful characters fans had come to know and love over the years. She and Lorelai ended the series (for the time being, anyway) the way it began: Laughing over a cup of coffee at Luke’s.
To say that Emily and Lorelai didn’t have the greatest relationship throughout the series is an understatement, but the Season 7 finale saw the Gilmore women at a sort of peace with each other. Though Emily was still nagging Lorelai about making changes to the inn (she and Richard thought Lorelai should add a Dragonfly Spa), she seemed pleased that Lorelai wanted to continue Friday night dinners. And though she wasn’t the one to say it, Richard told Lorelai he was proud of her — a sentiment we’re sure Emily shared, even if she’d never tell Lorelai herself.
The gruff diner proprietor wasn’t the best at expressing his feelings, but throwing together a last-minute surprise going away party for Rory said a lot: How much he cared about Rory, but more importantly, how much he still cared about Lorelai. His over-the-top efforts to make sure the party still happened despite the rainy forecast (including stitching together — by hand! — a giant tent to cover the town square) were beyond sweet, as was his declaration to Lorelai that he just wanted to see her happy (which led to their passionate kiss). And he opened the diner early so the girls could have one final goodbye breakfast together, proving that he understands the importance of mother-daughter bonding (and coffee — so much coffee). Luke also ended the series with joint custody of his daughter, though the less said about April, the better.
Quirky chef Sookie St. James was also enjoying the success of the Dragonfly, and still (adorably) squabbling with her husband, Jackson. Earlier in season seven, Sookie discovered she was pregnant for the third time, the result of Jackson hiding the fact that he didn’t get a vasectomy as promised after their second child was born. Despite that breach of trust, their marriage was still going strong at the end of the series, as was Sookie’s desire to see Luke and Lorelai reunited. She worked with the diner owner to help stage Rory’s surprise party, and in one final bit of successful matchmaking, gently coaxed him into thinking about how Lorelai would respond to the thoughtful gesture – and later spilled the beans to Lorelai that it was Luke who spearheaded the effort.
Many fans were disappointed by Lane’s Season 7 storyline, which saw the young newlywed suddenly saddled with twin boys after getting unexpectedly pregnant on her honeymoon with Zack. The overwhelmed new mom was initially planning on going on tour with her husband, who was offered a lead guitarist gig by another band, but ultimately bailed when she realized caring for two newborns on a tour bus would be impossible without constant help. While she seemed at peace with her decision, we couldn’t help but feel a bit sad for the formerly rebellious Lane, and hope she gets to live out her rock’n’roll dreams when “A Year in the Life” debuts.
The ruthless work ethic of Rory’s high school frenemy turned college roommate paid off at the end of Season 7, when she had her pick of prestigious post-grad options. While deciding between attending law school or med school, Paris ultimately landed on the latter, and enrolled in Harvard Medical School. (It helped that she already knew several of her fellow incoming classmates, having sized them up — and deemed them weak competition — during pre-med courses in their undergrad years at Yale.) And Paris found her true match in Doyle, whose devotion to her was one of the sweetest developments of the show’s later years. He took a cue from
The Huntzberger scion was on a bit of a professional rollercoaster in Season 7, when his once successful business dealings failed in epic fashion, leaving him completely broke and embroiled in a lawsuit. Despite that setback — and a brief return to his hard-partying ways — Logan eventually rebounded and decided to cut ties from his father for good, seeking a job at a startup in San Francisco. He wanted Rory to come with him to the west coast, and proposed to her; after thinking it over, Rory decided she wasn’t ready for marriage, and turned him down. She suggested that they try long distance again, but Logan didn’t want to continue their relationship without taking a step forward, and the pair broke up.
After his departure at the end of Season 3, Jess only pops up a handful of times throughout the rest of the series. But Luke’s nephew really grows up in that time period, finally admitting he’s in love with Rory (even if he doesn’t do it in the best way), helping found a small publishing company in Philadelphia, writing a short novel, and, finally, thanking Luke for everything (and giving him a check to pay back his kindness). When Jess meets up with Rory again early in Season 6, during her separation from Lorelai and her hiatus from Yale, he attributes his success to her, and helps her to realize she’s on the wrong path. Our last glimpse of him came later in Season 6, during a rough patch in Logan and Rory’s relationship. Rory visits Jess in Philadelphia, where they share a brief kiss before Rory admits she’s still dating Logan. Jess is initially upset, but they end things on good terms.
Things didn’t end well with Rory’s first boyfriend, with Dean ultimately dumping her three times over the course of the series. The pair rekindled their failed high school romance at the end of Season 4, when a married Dean cheated on his wife by sleeping with Rory. Lindsay eventually discovers the transgression and kicks him out, and he and Rory begin dating again, though the relationship is short-lived. They have trouble coordinating their schedules with Rory living at school and Dean working several jobs, and then Dean abruptly breaks up with Rory at a party at her grandparents’ house, citing the fact that he’ll never fit into her world. His last appearance in the series comes late in Season 5, when a bitter Dean tells Luke that Lorelai will never be satisfied with him, because the Gilmores want more than Stars Hollow — and they — have to offer.
At a loss for what to watch this week? From new TV, we’ve got you covered.
Yeah, you’ve probably heard about this one. “Gilmore Girls” fans have been waiting since 2007 to see Rory and Lorelai again, and they’ll get their chance Friday, November 25. True to its title, this revival heads to Stars Hollow to follow the Gilmore girls for one year — a new season for each episode — starting with winter and ending with fall. Will
Chris Pine plays a desperate father who learns the bank is going to take his family’s land, so he and his ex-con brother (Ben Foster) decide to rob the bank’s branches, and come into the crosshairs of an aging Texas Ranger (Jeff Bridges). The highly acclaimed thriller is out on DVD, Blu-ray, and On Demand November 22. The home release includes filmmaker Q&A; footage from the red carpet premiere; and the featurettes “Enemies Forever,” with an intimate look at the characters; “Visualizing the Heart of America,” on the setting and how the filmmakers used real locations to bring the story to life; and “Damaged Heroes,” exploring the cast performances.
Alia Shawkat plays Dory, who becomes obsessed with finding out what happened to her missing college acquaintance Chantal — even though none of her other friends care — in this new dark comedy/mystery on TBS. According to 
Just how close is Rebecca Bunch’s long-pursued, on-again/off-again, increasingly anxiety-riddled paramour Josh Chan to a meltdown big enough to mark him as a crazy ex-boyfriend?